Basilica di San Nicola, Bari: Where the Historical Saint Nicholas Actually Is
Autore: La Redazione di www.tourleaderpro.com
Last updated: April 2026. Complete guide for pilgrims and visitors: history, architecture, crypt, myrrh, and Bari's old city context.
Saint Nicholas of Myra was a bishop who lived in Lycia (modern Turkey) in the fourth century AD. He was known during his lifetime for extraordinary generosity — the specific acts attributed to him include giving bags of gold to a poor man's daughters as dowries, rescuing sailors in a storm, and restoring to life three young men who had been murdered and salted in a barrel by an innkeeper. He died around 343 AD and was buried in Myra. In 1087, a group of merchants from Bari sailed to Myra, stole his relics from under the nose of the Greek Orthodox monks who guarded them, brought them back to Puglia, and built one of the greatest Romanesque churches in southern Italy to house them.
This is the historical Saint Nicholas of Bari — not the invented commercial Christmas figure, not the Nordic folklore Sinterklaas, but a real fourth-century bishop whose relics have been in Bari for nearly a thousand years, whose tomb in the crypt of the Basilica di San Nicola still produces a clear liquid (the manna or myrrh of San Nicola) that is collected annually on his feast day (May 9) and distributed to pilgrims in small vials, and whose basilica is one of the two or three most important pilgrimage destinations in southern Italy.
History of the Basilica di San Nicola
The Theft of the Relics (1087)
The acquisition of Saint Nicholas's relics by the merchants of Bari is one of the better-documented relic thefts of the medieval period (and relic theft was extremely common — the term is furta sacra, sacred theft, and theologians developed extensive justifications for it). Sixty-two Baresian sailors disembarked at Myra, overcame the resistance of the three Greek Orthodox monks on duty, removed the relics from the tomb, and sailed home. They arrived in Bari on May 9, 1087.
The relics' arrival in Bari was immediate political capital. Myra was under Turkish control; having the relics meant the West rather than the East had custody of one of Christianity's most universally beloved saints. The Norman rulers of Puglia — Roger de Hauteville had taken the city from the Byzantines in 1071 — saw the theological and political advantage and immediately organized construction of a basilica to house the relics with appropriate magnificence. Construction began in 1087 and the crypt was consecrated in 1089, with Pope Urban II presiding — the same Urban II who would preach the First Crusade six years later.
The Construction of the Basilica
The Basilica di San Nicola was built in a new Norman Romanesque style that would become the template for churches across Puglia and southern Italy for a century. The building combines French Norman structural principles (thick walls, round arches, towers flanking the facade) with local Pugliese decorative vocabulary (blind arcading, carved portals, interlaced patterns) and Byzantine elements absorbed from the Greek heritage of the region. The result is neither purely Norman nor purely local but something new — the beginning of a specifically south-Italian Romanesque tradition that finds its most refined later expression in the Bari Cathedral (Cattedrale di San Sabino, built shortly after the basilica) and the cathedrals of Trani, Bitonto, and Ruvo.
The nave — three aisles divided by twelve columns of granite and cipollino marble — is wide and austere, the walls decorated with minimal ornament that focuses attention on the architectural structure itself. The facade has two asymmetrical towers (one was never completed to its designed height), a blind arcaded gallery in the central section, and three portals with carved archivolt decoration. The overall effect is massive and serene: a building that knows it contains something important and does not need to shout about it.
The Crypt and the Myrrh
The crypt below the main church floor is the heart of the Basilica di San Nicola. Entered from stairs on both sides of the apse, it is a lower church of six bays, its ceiling supported by twenty-six columns of different materials — white marble, cipollino, granite — collected from various ancient sources. The tomb of Saint Nicholas is beneath the altar, in the center of the crypt, sealed by a stone slab. Above the altar, an elaborate ciborium (canopy) frames the devotional space.
The manna or myrrh of San Nicola is a clear, slightly oily liquid that accumulates in the sealed tomb and is extracted annually through a small hole on the feast day of Saint Nicholas (May 9). The liquid has been analyzed; it is water, probably the result of condensation in the sealed tomb. The theological interpretation — miracle, myrrh, healing oil — is a matter of faith. What is not in dispute is that the annual extraction has occurred continuously since the twelfth century, and that the vials of manna di San Nicola distributed to pilgrims are among the most sought-after religious souvenirs in Puglia.
The Greek Orthodox Chapel
One of the most unusual aspects of the Basilica di San Nicola is the presence, in the lower level of the crypt, of a Greek Orthodox chapel dedicated to the saint — maintained by the Greek Orthodox community and used for regular Orthodox liturgical services. Saint Nicholas is enormously important in Orthodox Christianity (the eastern tradition adopted him as one of its most beloved saints long before he was filtered through Dutch and English folklore into Santa Claus), and the presence of an Orthodox chapel in a Catholic basilica in southern Italy reflects both the ecumenical significance of the saint and the region's deep historical ties to Byzantine Christianity.
The Orthodox chapel holds regular services including the commemoration of Nicholas's feast day on December 6 (the western date, different from the Orthodox liturgical calendar). When the Orthodox service coincides with the Catholic service upstairs, the basilica becomes a genuinely ecumenical space in a way that is rare in any Christian context.
Q&A: Visiting the Basilica di San Nicola
Is entry to the Basilica di San Nicola free?
Yes, the basilica is free to enter. A donation is appreciated. The treasury museum (Museo del Tesoro di San Nicola) in the adjacent building has a separate ticket of approximately €3–€5; it contains liturgical objects, reliquaries, and historical documents related to the basilica.
What are the opening hours of the Basilica di San Nicola?
Generally open daily 7am–8pm, with the crypt sometimes having separate access hours. The basilica closes during liturgical services. Verify current hours on the basilica's official website (basilicasannicola.it) before visiting — hours change for feast days and during restoration work.
Where exactly is the Basilica di San Nicola in Bari?
In the old city (Città Vecchia) of Bari, at Largo Abate Elia 13. The basilica faces a large square in the heart of the historic center; approaching from the seafront promenade (Lungomare), walk west through the old city's narrow streets — the twin towers of the basilica are visible from some distance. The Bari Centrale train station is approximately 15 minutes' walk from the basilica.
When is the feast day of Saint Nicholas in Bari?
The Bari feast of San Nicola is May 9, commemorating the arrival of the relics in 1087. The celebrations extend across May 7–9 and include a historical pageant (historical re-enactment of the arrival of the relics by sea), a procession, a nautical procession with the statue of Saint Nicholas carried on a boat in the harbor, and the annual extraction and distribution of the manna. May 9 in Bari is one of the major Italian religious festivals and draws enormous crowds from across the region and from pilgrims across the Mediterranean. December 6 (the traditional western feast of Saint Nicholas) is also celebrated but less elaborately.
What is the connection between Saint Nicholas of Bari and Santa Claus?
The historical Saint Nicholas of Myra/Bari became a popular saint in northwestern Europe from the medieval period, particularly in the Netherlands where he was known as Sinterklaas. Dutch colonists brought the Sinterklaas tradition to New Amsterdam (later New York), where it merged with local winter celebration customs in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Washington Irving's satirical history of New York (1809) and Clement Clarke Moore's poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas" (1823) consolidated the North American Santa Claus tradition. The commercial elaboration into the global red-suited Christmas figure occurred through Coca-Cola advertising in the 1930s. The historical original — a fourth-century Lycian bishop — is now in a crypt in Bari, Puglia.
Can you visit the crypt of the Basilica di San Nicola?
Yes. The crypt is open as part of the regular basilica visit. The descent is from stairs on either side of the main church apse. Photography is permitted in the basilica but discouraged in the crypt, particularly during moments of devotion. During moments of prayer or veneration at the tomb, maintain appropriate silence.
What else should I see in Bari besides the Basilica di San Nicola?
Bari's old city (Città Vecchia) is a dense medieval labyrinth worth an hour of wandering: narrow streets, courtyard houses, women sitting outside making orecchiette pasta by hand (particularly on Strada Arco Basso). The Cathedral of San Sabino (built slightly after the Basilica di San Nicola in a related Pugliese Romanesque style) is on the opposite side of the old city. The Castello Svevo (Swabian Castle, built for Frederick II in 1233 on Norman foundations) on the harbor. And Bari's fish market (Mercato del Pesce), open from early morning, is one of the best in Puglia.
The Norman Legacy in Puglia: Understanding the Basilica's Context
The Basilica di San Nicola was built by Norman conquerors who had displaced Byzantine Greek authority over Puglia in the mid-eleventh century. The Normans — descendants of Viking settlers in northern France who had also conquered England (1066) — were remarkable cultural synthesizers: in Sicily, they produced a hybrid Norman-Arab-Byzantine court; in Puglia, they produced an architecture that borrowed from France, Lombardy, and the Byzantine decorative tradition simultaneously.
The churches built in the half-century following the Basilica di San Nicola — the Cathedral of Trani (begun 1098), the Cathedral of Bitonto (1175), the Cathedral of Ruvo (1200) — form a remarkable architectural cluster of Pugliese Romanesque, each a variation on the template the San Nicola basilica established. A road trip connecting these cathedrals, beginning in Bari and moving north along the Adriatic coast, is one of the best architectural itineraries in southern Italy and one of the least-known to international visitors.
What Nobody Tells You About the Basilica di San Nicola
The throne in the crypt — the Episcopal Throne of Elias, a massive carved marble seat dating to the eleventh century — is one of the finest examples of Pugliese Romanesque sculpture in existence. Its carved legs depict three human figures supporting the seat: the figures are thought to represent heretics or conquered enemies bearing the weight of orthodox Christianity. The throne is functional; the Archbishop of Bari still uses it for specific liturgical ceremonies.
The basilica has a small but distinguished treasury museum (Museo del Tesoro) adjacent to the church that contains objects that would be headline pieces in a larger institution: Byzantine reliquaries in gold and enamel, a twelfth-century silver icon of Saint Nicholas, historical documents in Greek and Latin charting the basilica's history. The treasury museum is visited by almost no one who is not a specialist. Admission is minimal.
The basilica is not primarily a tourist attraction. It is a functioning pilgrimage church that receives pilgrims from across the Orthodox and Catholic Christian worlds year-round. The pilgrims are mostly invisible to casual visitors — they are in the crypt, praying quietly, touching the tomb, buying the vials of manna. Being aware of this when you visit changes how you move through the space.
Internal Links
- Basilica di Sant'Antonio Padova: Complete Pilgrim Guide
- Basilica di Collemaggio L'Aquila: The Church That Invented the Jubilee
- Polignano a Mare: Puglia's Most Dramatic Coastal Town
- Egnazia Archaeological Park: Puglia's Ancient Roman City
- Italy Fishing Villages: Puglia's Most Beautiful Coastal Towns
- Ostuni: The White City of Puglia
- Italian Baroque Churches: The Most Spectacular to Visit