Slightly — but the Greek Theatre saves it
Taormina is beautiful but feels more like an international resort than a Sicilian town. If you're expecting raw, authentic Sicily, you'll be disappointed. If you want elegance with a view, it delivers.
What lives up to the hype
The Greek Theatre with Etna smoking behind it is genuinely one of Europe's great views. Isola Bella beach is beautiful. The Corso Umberto passeggiata at sunset is elegant. The cable car ride down to the beach is fun.
What disappoints
Prices are double the Sicilian average. Cruise ship crowds mob the Corso midday. Restaurants serve "international" food rather than real Sicilian cooking. The town is tiny — you see everything in a few hours. And it can feel sanitized compared to Palermo or Catania.
The verdict for different travellers
Luxury travellers and couples: Taormina is perfect. Budget travellers: you'll feel nickeled and dimed. Foodies: go to Palermo or Catania instead. First-time Sicily visitors: include Taormina but don't make it your only stop.
Bottom line
Taormina isn't overrated for what it is — a beautiful, upscale resort town. It's overrated if you expect it to represent Sicily. See it, enjoy it, then drive to Catania for the real thing.