Lake Como vs Lake Orta: Fame Against Intimacy in the Italian Lakes

Lake Como is the most internationally famous Italian lake. Lake Orta is 45km away, receives 1% of Como's visitor volume, has a medieval village untouched by commercial development, and the most extraordinary small island in the Italian lake district — Isola San Giulio, where a Benedictine convent of enclosed nuns has been operating since 962 AD and the population has not exceeded 70 in 1,000 years. The comparison is not actually fair to Como.

Read the guide →

Lake Orta: What It Actually Is

Lago d'Orta (Lake Orta) is a small lake in the Piemonte region, 45km southwest of Lake Como across the Piedmontese hills: 13.4 km² surface area, 143m maximum depth, 800m above sea level at the surface (it's higher than Como), and oriented north-south between the Mottarone mountain and the Monte Mesma hills. The lake is moraine-dammed — it was formed by the retreat of glaciers at the end of the last Ice Age, approximately 10,000 years ago, and the specific moraine that dams its southern end is what makes it ecologically distinct from the larger Pre-Alpine lakes.

The lake's human settlement: the town of Orta San Giulio (population 1,100) is on a small promontory on the western shore — a perfectly preserved medieval village with no significant modern development. The historic centre of Orta San Giulio was declared off-limits to private vehicles in the 1980s; since then, the medieval street fabric (the Piazza Motta — the lakeside market square with its 16th-century Palazzo della Comunità, the arcaded medieval building on the waterfront — Via Olina, the covered market street) has been protected from the pressures of parking and vehicle access that have distorted comparable Italian lake towns. The specific preservation quality: Orta San Giulio's historic centre looks more like a 16th-century Piedmontese lake town than any comparable site in northern Italy.

Isola San Giulio and the enclosed Benedictine nuns: Isola San Giulio is a small island (275m long, 140m wide) 400m from the Orta San Giulio waterfront, accessible by rowing boat (barchetta, €5 return, oared by the boatmen who have been running the service for generations). The island has been inhabited since the 4th century AD — the Basilica di San Giulio (4th century foundation, rebuilt in Romanesque in the 11th century) marks the place where Saint Julius of Novara is said to have driven the serpents from the island (a Christianised version of a pre-Christian sacred island tradition). The Benedictine convent of Mater Ecclesiae has enclosed approximately 70 nuns on the island since 962 AD — they are not visible to visitors (the enclosed life means no public contact), but their presence on the island is legally documented and ecclesiastically continuous for 1,062 years. Walking the Via del Silenzio (the single path that circles the island, 10-minute walk) with this history in mind is the most specific Lake Orta experience.

Lake Como vs Lake Orta: The Numbers

Lake Como: 146 km² surface area, 410m maximum depth (Italy's deepest lake), 35+ million annual visitors, €300–600/night average hotel price at Bellagio, George Clooney's villa in Laglio, the Tremezzina UNESCO-candidate garden district, ferry connections to 50+ towns. Lake Orta: 13.4 km² surface area, 143m depth, approximately 300,000 annual visitors, €100–200/night average hotel price at Orta San Giulio, the best-preserved medieval lake town in Piedmont, Isola San Giulio with its 1,000-year Benedictine enclosure, no celebrity association. The visitor-to-beauty ratio: Lake Orta receives 100× fewer visitors than Lake Como with arguably equivalent scenic quality (the specific character is different but the beauty is comparable) and significantly lower prices.

What Lake Orta Has That Lake Como Doesn't

The Via del Silenzio: The path circling Isola San Giulio has been maintained by the Benedictine nuns — signs at intervals along the path quote contemplative texts without attribution, inviting visitors to walk in silence. The signs are specific and beautifully crafted: not generic inspirational quotes but passages from the monastic tradition that engage with the experience of an enclosed community maintaining silence on an island for 1,000 years. Walking the 10-minute island circuit in genuine silence is the most unusual single Italian tourist experience available. The Sacro Monte di Orta: The UNESCO-designated Sacro Monte di Orta (one of the nine Sacri Monti of Piedmont and Lombardy, all UNESCO) is a devotional landscape on the hillside above the lake — 20 chapels built between 1590 and 1770, containing life-size terracotta sculpture groups illustrating the life of Saint Francis of Assisi. The most complete and most artistic of all the Sacri Monti circuits. Free, open daily. 20-minute walk from Orta San Giulio. The Mottarone mountain: The 1,491m summit accessible by chairlift from Stresa (Lake Maggiore side — Lake Orta and Lake Maggiore share the Mottarone as their common watershed). The Mottarone summit provides simultaneous views of Lake Maggiore, Lake Orta, and on clear days, Monte Rosa (4,634m) and the full Alpine chain from the Matterhorn to the Bernina group. The cable car from Stresa to Mottarone has been temporarily suspended after the 2021 cable car accident; verify current operational status before planning.

Is Lake Orta worth visiting?

Lake Orta is one of the most genuinely underappreciated Italian lakes — a perfectly preserved medieval lake town (Orta San Giulio), the most extraordinary small island in the Italian lake district (Isola San Giulio, with the 1,062-year Benedictine enclosure), the UNESCO Sacro Monte devotional landscape above the town, and 300,000 annual visitors (compared to 35 million at Lake Como). Prices are 40–50% lower than Lake Como equivalents. The absence of celebrity association and mass tourism infrastructure is the point — Lake Orta provides what Lake Como used to provide before it became a luxury tourism product. Accessible from Milan: 90 minutes by car (A26 motorway north, then SP229) or 2 hours by train+bus (Milan to Novara, then bus to Orta).

How far is Lake Orta from Lake Como?

Lake Orta is 45km southwest of Lake Como — 55 minutes by car via the SS33 and SP229 (or 1.5 hours if combining the visit with a stop in Stresa on Lake Maggiore, which lies between Como and Orta geographically). There is no direct public transport connection between Lake Como and Lake Orta — the route requires train to Novara or Stresa and then bus or taxi to Orta. Lake Orta is most efficiently combined with a Lake Maggiore visit (15km separate them, connected by the Mottarone road) or with the Piedmontese cities of Novara (35km) and Verbania (25km). From Milan: 90 minutes by car, 2 hours by train+bus.

What is special about Isola San Giulio?

Isola San Giulio is a small island (275m long, 140m wide) 400m from the shore of Orta San Giulio, accessible by rowing boat (€5 return). The island has the Basilica di San Giulio (4th-century foundation, 11th-century Romanesque rebuilding, one of the oldest continuously functioning Christian churches in Piedmont) and the Benedictine convent of Mater Ecclesiae — an enclosed religious community of approximately 70 nuns that has been continuously in residence since 962 AD. The Via del Silenzio (the single path circling the island, 10 minutes to walk) has contemplative texts from the monastic tradition placed at intervals by the nuns, inviting visitors to walk in silence. The experience of walking this path — the lake visible on both sides of the tiny island, the 1,000-year monastic presence, the silence requested — is unlike any other Italian tourist experience.

Lake Orta and Piedmontese Culture

Lake Orta is in Piedmont rather than Lombardy — the distinction matters for food culture (Piedmontese risotto with local cèpe mushrooms, the Orta San Giulio restaurants serving the specific Novarese food tradition including paniscia di Novara, a rice and vegetable stew more hearty than the Milanese risotto), for wine (the Colline Novaresi DOC wines, including the Boca DOC — a Nebbiolo-based wine from the volcanic hills 15km east of Orta, one of the most distinctive and least known Italian reds), and for the specific cultural atmosphere. Orta San Giulio is a Piedmontese lake town, not a Lombard one — the architecture, the food, the social pace, and the cultural references all reflect the Savoy-period Piedmontese tradition rather than the Milanese commercial one. Related: Lake Como guide, Italian lakes comparison.

Discover Lake Orta

Isola San Giulio rowing boat, Via del Silenzio walk, Sacro Monte UNESCO circuit, and the combined Orta-Maggiore itinerary from Milan.

La Redazione di TourLeaderPro.com

Italian Volcanic Geography: Etna, Vesuvius, and the Chain of Active Volcanoes

Italy sits on the collision zone between the African tectonic plate (moving northeast at approximately 2cm per year) and the Eurasian plate — the subduction of the African plate beneath the Eurasian produces the volcanism that characterises the southern Italian and Sicilian landscape. The active Italian volcanic system:

Mount Etna (3,329m, Sicily): The most active volcano in Europe — currently in a state of continuous low-level activity with major eruptive episodes every 2–5 years. The 2021 Southeast Crater eruption produced lava fountains visible from Catania (30km away) and ash deposits that periodically close Catania airport (CTA). The volcanic landscape of Etna's flanks (the lava fields, the extinct parasitic craters, the Valle del Bove caldera) is entirely accessible by car (the SS120 and SS185 ring roads around the mountain), and Etna's summit is accessible by cable car from Rifugio Sapienza (2,900m, then guided summit tour to 3,300m, €28 cable car + €62 guided summit, etnatickets.com) when the crater is in its quiet phases. Vesuvius (1,281m, Campania): The only active mainland European volcano, in a state of dormancy (last eruption 1944) but seismically monitored continuously by the INGV Vesuvius Observatory (the most important volcanic monitoring station in Europe). The summit is accessible from the Vesuvius car park by a 45-minute walk (€10 entry, bus from Herculaneum or Pompeii). The view from the crater rim: Napoli below, the Campi Flegrei caldera to the west, the Sorrento peninsula, and the gulf of Naples. Stromboli: The "Lighthouse of the Mediterranean" — a volcanic island 85km northeast of Sicily with continuous small eruptions from the summit crater (the Sciara del Fuoco, the fire-scar on the northwest face, is the most dramatic active volcano visual in Europe). Accessible by ferry from Milazzo (Sicily) or Napoli. Summit climb permitted to 400m without guide; summit to 924m requires licensed guide (Stromboli Adventures, stromboliadventures.it, €30–40).

Can you visit Etna in Sicily?

Etna (3,329m) is accessible year-round with different access levels depending on eruption status. The standard visitor route: drive or bus to Rifugio Sapienza (2,900m, southern flank) and take the cable car to 2,900m (€28, etnatickets.com), then join the guided summit tour to the active crater area at 3,300m (€62 additional, mandatory with guide for the summit zone). The cable car operates weather and eruption-permitting (check etnatickets.com for status). The lower Etna flanks (the Valle del Bove caldera road, the lava field landscapes near Zafferana Etnea, and the hiking trails of the Piano Provenzana area on the northern flank) are accessible by car and free to explore without guide. The most dramatic Etna experience: the eruption viewpoint at night when the lava fountains are visible from the Refugio Sapienza area — no entry required to see the summit illuminated from 3km distance.

Italian Textile Traditions: The Crafts That Defined Prosperity

Italian textile production is the oldest continuous luxury manufacturing tradition in Europe — the specific techniques and production centres that made medieval and Renaissance Italian textiles the most valuable commodities in the known world still exist, in reduced but genuine form, as working craft traditions:

Lucca silk: Lucca (Tuscany) was the most important silk-weaving city in Europe from the 12th to the 15th centuries — Lucchese silk merchants (the Guinigi, the Buonvisi families) established trading operations across Europe, and Lucchese silk-weaving techniques were used in the liturgical vestments of every European cathedral. The Lucca silk industry was disrupted by the 14th-century Black Death and subsequent political instability but never fully disappeared. The Antico Setificio Fiorentino (Firenze, Via Bartolini 4, setificiofiorentino.it — the oldest working silk mill in Italy, established 1786, using 18th-century warping equipment designed by Leonardo da Vinci) produces Florentine silk damask and taffeta for interior decoration and fashion houses. Visits by appointment. Burano lace: The Burano Island lace-making tradition (Venice lagoon) dates to the 16th century — the punto in aria (point in air) technique, building lace from thread alone without a backing fabric, was developed in Burano and was the most technically complex textile skill in European history. By the 19th century the tradition had almost died; a school was established in 1872 to preserve it (the Museo del Merletto, Piazza Galuppi 187, Burano, €5, museomerletto.visitmuve.it). Currently approximately 15–20 practising Burano lace makers survive, most over 60. The making of a single square centimetre of punto in aria takes approximately 1 hour of skilled work. Sardinian tapestry: The arazzo sardo (Sardinian tapestry, woven on horizontal looms from the Barbagia tradition) is a specifically Sardinian textile — geometric designs in natural dye colours (madder red, indigo blue, weld yellow) woven into rugs, wall hangings, and seat coverings. The centre of production is Mogoro (Oristano province) and Nule (Nuoro province). The Tessile di Sardegna cooperative (cooperativatessile.it) documents the tradition and sells directly from the weavers.

Where can I buy genuine Italian handmade textiles?

Genuine handmade Italian textiles by tradition: Burano lace (punto in aria) — buy directly from the Museo del Merletto shop (Piazza Galuppi 187, Burano, Venice lagoon, €50–500+ for individual pieces, the museum can recommend active lace makers whose work is for sale); Lucca silk damask — Antico Setificio Fiorentino (Via Bartolini 4, Florence, by appointment, the most authentic source for Florentine silk); Sardinian arazzo tapestry — cooperativatessile.it or the market in Mogoro (Oristano province) during the Mostra dell'Artigianato di Mogoro (August — the most important Sardinian handicraft fair). Avoid generic "Italian textiles" sold in tourist shops near major attractions — these are almost universally Chinese-manufactured with Italian brand labelling.

Book top-rated tours & skip-the-line tickets for this trip